Indirect questions with da li and question words
In short
Embedded question = same opening word as the direct question, statement order, full stop.
| Direct | Embedded |
|---|---|
| Da li dolazi? | Ne znam da li dolazi. |
| Da li imate sobu? | Pitam da li imate sobu. |
| Gde je stanica? | Ne znam gde je stanica. |
| Kad stiže voz? | Pitala je kad stiže voz. |
da asserts, da li asks: Znam da dolazi (I know he is) vs Ne znam da li dolazi (I don't know whether he is). Clitics stay in second position inside the clause: ne znam gde je stanica.
A2 · Lesson 25 · Indirect questions: Ne znam da li dolazi
The full explanation, from the lesson that teaches this rule
At A1 you learnt to ask questions directly: Da li dolazi? (Is he coming?), Gde je stanica? (Where is the station?). Very often, though, you do not ask the question itself — you talk about it. You say that you do not know the answer, or you pass on a question someone else asked: I don't know whether he's coming. She asked me where the station is. This is an indirect question: a question tucked inside a bigger sentence, after a verb like know, ask, tell me or see.
Which word opens the embedded question
Serbian keeps this very simple. The opening word of the embedded question is the same word the direct question started with. There are two cases.
- A yes/no question starts with da li, so the embedded version starts with da li too: Da li dolazi? → Ne znam da li dolazi. (I don't know whether he's coming.) English uses whether or if here; Serbian just keeps da li.
- A question with a question word (gde, kad, ko, šta, zašto, koliko, kako, koji) keeps that question word and nothing else: Gde je stanica? → Ne znam gde je stanica. (I don't know where the station is.)
| Direct question | Embedded question | Opens with |
|---|---|---|
| Da li dolazi? | Ne znam da li dolazi. | da li (yes/no) |
| Da li imate sobu? | Pitam da li imate sobu. | da li (yes/no) |
| Gde je stanica? | Ne znam gde je stanica. | the question word |
| Kad stiže voz? | Pitala je kad stiže voz. | the question word |
| Koliko košta karta? | Reci mi koliko košta karta. | the question word |
Word order and punctuation
Inside the bigger sentence the question is no longer a question in its own right. It takes the ordinary statement word order you already use, and the whole sentence ends with a full stop, not a question mark, unless the main clause is itself a question (Znaš li gde je stanica? — Do you know where the station is?). Clitics such as je, sam, se, mi still go in second position inside the embedded clause, right after da li or the question word: Ne znam gde je stanica. Pitam se kad se vraća.
The same construction works after any verb that can take a question as its content: znati (know), pitati (ask), pitati se (wonder), reći (tell), videti (see), razumeti (understand), and after phrases like nije važno (it doesn't matter) or nisam siguran (I'm not sure). The verb before the question does not change anything: Pitam da li dolazi. Reci mi da li dolazi. Nije važno da li dolazi.
The trap: da against da li
In lesson 24 you learnt da after znati, misliti, reći: Znam da dolazi means I know that he is coming — a fact, asserted. Ne znam da li dolazi means I don't know whether he is coming — an open question, no assertion at all. Both stand after znati, both are followed by a present-tense clause, and only the little li tells them apart. Drop it, and you have said the opposite of what you meant.
| Sentence | Meaning | What it says |
|---|---|---|
| Znam da dolazi. | I know that he is coming. | fact — he is coming |
| Ne znam da li dolazi. | I don't know whether he is coming. | open question — maybe, maybe not |
| Rekla je da ima sobu. | She said that she has a room. | fact — she has one |
| Pitala je da li ima sobu. | She asked whether there is a room. | open question |
When the main verb is negated (ne znam, nisam siguran, ne vidim), the embedded clause is STILL introduced by da li or the question word, exactly as after a positive verb. Ne znam da li dolazi — not ne znam da dolazi, which would be an odd, half-finished claim. And the embedded verb itself is not negated just because the main verb is.
You may hear or read a shorter variant that puts li straight after the verb: Ne znam može li doći. Recognise it if you meet it, but do not use it yet — in this course you always say Ne znam da li može doći.
The two verbs you will use most
| znati (know) | pitati (ask) | |
|---|---|---|
| ja | znam | pitam |
| ti | znaš | pitaš |
| on / ona | zna | pita |
| mi | znamo | pitamo |
| vi | znate | pitate |
| oni | znaju | pitaju |
| past (m / f) | znao / znala | pitao / pitala |
With pitati the person asked is a direct object in the accusative — Pitao me je gde stanujem (He asked me where I live) — and the question follows straight after. Note that the tense inside the embedded clause stays as it was in the original question: he asked Gde stanuješ?, so I report pitao me je gde stanujem with the present, even though the asking happened in the past.
Check what you read
3 of the 16 questions this lesson asks in the app. Type the form or pick the answer.
Which sentence means "I don't know whether he is coming"?
Which sentence means "I know that he is coming"?
Which sentence means "She asked when the train arrives"?
Examples from the course
The marked word is where the rule applies. Press play to hear the sentence.
Reci mi koliko košta karta.
Tell me how much the ticket costs. (to one person)
Pitam se kad se vraća.
I wonder when she is coming back.
Ne znam gde je stanica.
I don't know where the station is.
Ne znam da li dolazi.
I don't know whether he is coming.
Znaš li gde je stanica?
Do you know where the station is? (informal)
Pitala je kad stiže voz.
She asked when the train arrives.
Pitao me je gde stanujem.
He asked me where I live.
Pitam da li imate sobu.
I'm asking whether you have a room. (formal you)
Obavestite me da li let kasni.
Let me know whether the flight is late. (formal you)
Ne znam da li može doći.
I don't know whether he can come.
Sentences in the course that use this rule: 31
Try it yourself
Translate a sentence that uses this rule. The check marks the word that went wrong and names the rule behind it, as in the app.
Sentences
Write it in Serbian
Tell me how much the ticket costs. (to one person)